Country:
 

Comparative test: 46 Cool Coolers

hwi-h Articles » Comparative test: 46 Cool Coolers

Comparative test: 46 Cool Coolers Comparative test: 46 Cool Coolers
46 current CPU-coolers extensively tested

Heatpipes

Up to a few years ago we’d never heard of them. In the meantime every self-respecting manufacturer uses them: heatpipes. It’s an effective, albeit expensive, technology to increase CPU-cooler efficiency. The aim of using heatpipes is to displace heat quickly and efficiently. When using large coolers the heatpipes are used to move heat as quickly as possible from the bottom to the top of the cooling block. In fact a heatpipe is nothing more than an aluminium or copper tube filled with a fluid. This can be water, but more frequently ammonia or ethanol is used.

The working principle is quite simple. The bottom end of the heatpipe is located directly above the processor and as such is in direct connection with the heat source. The liquid contained in the heatpipe will absorb the heat and by consequence will evaporate. At the top-end of the heatpipe is a cooling block which in its turn absorbs the heat from the evaporated liquid, effectively cooling the gas, which in its turn condensates again and trickles down to the bottom of the heatpipe. Once below, the (once again) fluid absorbs the heat from the processor, etc. in a continuous cycle.

Not all heatpipes are equal though. Amongst other things the materials out of which the heatpipe is constructed and the type of fluid it contains determine its efficiency. In any case, dissipating heat by means of a heatpipe is much quicker than through a solid piece of metal.

doorsnedeheatpipe
Heatpipes can be used to increase the efficiency of a CPU-cooler.

Peltier

Two coolers in our test use a different technology to conduct heat away from the processor. A Peltier-element is a platelet which gets really cold on one side and seriously hot on the other. Throuch such an element the heat generated by the processor is conducted directly upwards thereby actively cooling the CPU. The drawback of the Peltier-element is that it uses quite a lot of energy whereby the top-side of the element can become hotter than the processor itself. A Peltier uses about 60 Watts which means that the cooling block and the fan have to cope with double the amount of heat. This heat will not complete disappear from the case. Coolers which use such elements therefore have both advantages and disadvantages. The advantage is that the processor is cooled much more efficiently; disadvantage is that a lot more heat has to be dealt with.

Advertisement

Related articles cpu coolers

SlashdotPost to Slashdot Digg thisDigg this Add to del.icio.usAdd to del.icio.us

Hardware.Info in other countries: België - Nederland - United Kingdom - United States